My Candy Love: Which one?

From the game "My Candy Love" [link] picture found on BING

From right to left...

Castiel, the Rebel
Likes; Electric guitar
Hates; being ordered around
Horoscope: Leo

Nathaniel, the Class President
Likes; Crime novels
Hates: Sweets
Horoscope: Aquarius

Lysander, the Poet
Likes: poetry
Hates: quick judgement
Horoscope: Scorpio